Jack-O-Lantern (page 2)

I love it!! I think you did an excellent job!!

January 29, 2004

Libby, Just goes to show why you clog my favorites! I love this LO, but my eye does kinda go right to the PB pumpkin on this page. I love it on the other side, but here, it just makes me wanna look at it first. Maybe it's because it's brighter in color? I dunno, you could maybe chalk or ink it to make it darker? I think this page would look just as good without it, you do such fabulous work. I would leave it off because it detracts from the gorgeous photo below it. JMO, hope that helps you some!

January 29, 2004

Gorgeous! I love everything about it!!

January 29, 2004

I dont think it takes away anything at all I love it!

January 28, 2004

Your choice of paper and layout of your photos always works well Libby,great page,kim

January 28, 2004

I loved the fabric you used on this page, looks great.

January 28, 2004

The little pumpkin is a great embellishment. Both your pages turn out terrific! :)

January 28, 2004

I love these pumpkin LOs they are really beautiful! Skyla

January 28, 2004

Thanks everyone for your honesty. I think when something just doesn't feel quite right, it probably isn't! I know a few people felt it was fine, but since my first instinct was to take it off, and a few others concur....I am going to remove it. Libby

January 28, 2004

This LO is absolutely gorgeous. Love the gingham and stitching!

January 28, 2004

Well I thought I was in the minority, I am glad some others agree, I kinda think the page does not need that pumpkin and it does draw your eye. The layout is absolutley lovely!

January 28, 2004

Great job here, too!! Love the gingham. I agree with the above two ladies....I wold do without the "fake" pumpkin. The real pumpkin speaks enough on its own!

January 28, 2004

Lib, great pages. I love that you were able to use your selvage edged fabric, it's a great look. I think I agree with you about the second pumpkin, I don't think you need it. IMHO the use of the same paper and fabric ties the two pages together, but the PB pumpkin pulls my eye away from the real deal :) luv, Joc.

January 28, 2004

First I love the pages, they are gorgeous! I like to test pages by where the eye goes. I have to tell you the truth Libby, my eye first goes to the Paper Bliss pumpkin and kind of gets stuck there. That isn't necessarily a bad thing. I can tell my eye wants to go right to the photo below the PB pumpkin but it doesn't seem natural. It is such a great photo. The PB does pull the two pages together. Your photos are great and I love the layouts.

January 28, 2004

I think the little pumpkin is cute....

January 28, 2004

Libby~ This is so pretty! I love the colors and the frayed fabric is cool..I didn't really notice the little pumpkin until after I read your note and then I went back and gave it a second look...I think it's fine..nice job! bunny

January 28, 2004

I love it and the little pumpkin is cute.

January 28, 2004

Libby I love these pages!! I like how you offset different textures as your background. I don't think that way! LOL I sat here and looked at the PB pumpkin and came to the discision that he is okay. I like how it gives a small amount of a different shade of orange. He is small enough he doesn't really detract from the photo.

January 28, 2004

Cheers